Fully virtual · Serving business owners in Oklahoma and beyond Make a Payment(405) 844-6442brooks@cannon-brown.comClient Portal

Key takeaways

  • In Hee v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-53 (June 23, 2026), the Tax Court disallowed a company’s deductions for salaries and benefits paid to the owner’s spouse and three children.
  • The court applied “close scrutiny” to family pay and asked whether it was reasonable and paid purely for services, and found the company had not documented the hours or the work.
  • The disallowed pay was treated as constructive dividends to the owner, taxed again on the personal return.
  • The case also sustained civil fraud penalties against the owner and the company, which kept tax years as far back as 2003 open.
  • Paying family members can still work well when the job is real, the pay fits the work, and timesheets and job descriptions back it up.

The short answer: you can pay your spouse and children through your company, but the pay has to be for real work, at a reasonable rate, and you need records that prove it. In Hee v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-53, decided June 23, 2026, the U.S. Tax Court disallowed years of salaries and benefits a family company paid to the owner’s spouse and three children, mainly because the company could not show what work was done or how many hours were worked. The court then treated that pay as dividends to the owner. For any business owner with family on payroll, the case is a clear checklist of what the IRS looks for.

What happened

The case involved two consolidated dockets: Albert S.N. Hee and Wendy R. Hee (Docket No. 24068-22) and Waimana Enterprises, Inc. (Docket No. 24077-22). Waimana was a C corporation in Hawaii, and Mr. Hee was its sole shareholder and president from 2003 through 2012. Waimana acted as a holding company for several subsidiaries in telecommunications, network construction, and captive insurance, and it provided management services to them.

Waimana paid salaries to Mr. Hee’s wife and their three children. According to the opinion:

  • The children began as part-time employees and, by 2006, two of them were on salary, with the third added in 2008. Their combined pay ran from about $46,000 in 2006 to about $151,000 in 2010. Testimony described summer and holiday work such as copying documents, attending executive meetings, and maintaining company property.
  • Mrs. Hee was paid from about $34,000 to about $79,000 a year from 2003 through 2012. Her role included reviewing and editing documents, research, attending social events, and acting as a sounding board. She did not have an office at the company.
  • Benefits for the family employees, including profit-sharing contributions, 401(k) matches, and insurance, reached roughly $100,000 a year in 2010 and 2011.

The IRS audit went well beyond family pay. It also questioned family travel deducted as business travel, a child’s college tuition, massage therapy, meals, and large shareholder loans. This article focuses on the family pay, the part most relevant to owners who employ relatives.

What the IRS argued

The IRS said the family salaries and benefits were not deductible business expenses. Because the money went to the owner’s family, the IRS also treated it as constructive dividends to Mr. Hee, meaning the same dollars were taxed on the personal return. The IRS asserted civil fraud penalties under section 6663 against Mr. Hee and the company. It did not pursue fraud penalties against Mrs. Hee.

The taxpayers argued that their outside accountant had told Mr. Hee he could pay his children as long as they were working, that the children were the lowest-paid people at the company, and that company employees could confirm the children worked during breaks.

What the court decided, and why

The court started with the rule in section 162(a)(1): a business may deduct “a reasonable allowance” for pay for services actually performed. Under the regulations, pay must be reasonable in amount and paid purely for services. When family is involved, the court said, the facts get close scrutiny to see whether there was a true employer-employee relationship or whether the money was paid because of the family relationship.

Measured against that standard, the records fell short for each person:

  • One daughter was a full-time university student for most of the period, studied abroad, and held other jobs. In one stretch, payroll records showed 2,008 hours of work for the company, but she testified she did not work those hours, and a company employee explained the hours were entered automatically for salaried staff to generate pay.
  • The second daughter’s hours were recorded for two years, but the type of work was never documented, and for later years neither the hours nor the work were recorded. She was also a full-time student with other jobs.
  • The son testified he managed and repaired a property the company owned near his college. The company recorded his hours for one year but not what he did, and the court found his account uncorroborated.
  • Mrs. Hee’s description of her work was not supported by other evidence, and one of the children testified that she stayed home with the family for much of the period.

The court held that none of the family pay or benefits was deductible. It then treated the salaries and benefits as constructive dividends to the Hees, reasoning that money a company sends to the owner’s family benefits the owner.

On penalties, the court found clear and convincing evidence of fraud as to Mr. Hee and Waimana, based on the whole record, including inadequate records, personal expenses reclassified as business, and information given to the outside accountants that was incomplete or misleading. Because fraud was found, the normal three-year assessment window did not apply, and the IRS could assess tax for years going back to 2003 and 2004. The court sustained the fraud penalties, which under section 6663 equal 75% of the underpayment attributable to fraud, and directed that the final numbers be computed under Tax Court Rule 155.

Lessons for business owners

Most owners who employ family are nowhere near the facts of this case. Still, the court’s reasoning on family pay applies to everyone, and it’s where the case started to unravel. Here is what we take from it:

  1. Write down the job. A short job description for each family employee, listing the actual tasks, answers the first question the IRS will ask.
  2. Track real hours. Timesheets should reflect time actually worked. Hours that are filled in automatically for salaried staff did not help here; they hurt, because the employee testified she did not work them.
  3. Make the pay fit the work. Pay a family member about what you would pay an unrelated person for the same job and hours. A full-time salary for summer and holiday work invites a challenge.
  4. Check the calendar. If a family member is a full-time student or works another full-time job, the hours you pay for need to be believable alongside that schedule.
  5. Benefits follow the pay. Retirement contributions and insurance for a family employee are deductible on the same terms as the salary. If the job can’t be supported, the benefits fall too.
  6. Keep personal and business separate. Family trips, tuition, and personal costs run through the company drew the court’s attention to everything else. Clean books protect the legitimate deductions.
  7. Give your tax preparer complete information. Relying on an accountant’s advice helps when the accountant had the full and accurate facts, and not otherwise.

Done properly, putting your children on payroll is a well-established strategy. Our page on hiring your children walks through the rules, the payroll tax treatment by entity type, and the timesheets and pay records we set up. If family members travel with you on company business, our business travel deductions page explains how to separate business days from personal ones. And an accountable plan gives your company a written, documented way to reimburse legitimate business expenses so that personal and business costs stay apart.

How we help

At Cannon & Brown Tax Advisors, family payroll is part of the tax plan, not an afterthought. We help set reasonable pay for each role, put job descriptions and timesheets in place, and keep the books clean so the deductions hold up if the IRS ever asks. Your tax strategist reviews every recommendation. If you already pay family members, or you’re considering it, a free tax analysis is a good place to see whether your setup would stand up to the kind of review in this case.

This article is educational and is not tax advice for your situation. Tax law may change, which may change these rules and numbers.

Want to know how this applies to you?

In a free tax analysis, we’ll look at your numbers and show you the strategies that fit your business and your goals.

Get My Free Tax Analysis

Common questions

What did the Tax Court decide in Hee v. Commissioner?

In T.C. Memo. 2026-53, decided June 23, 2026, the court disallowed a C corporation’s deductions for salaries and benefits paid to the owner’s spouse and children because the company did not document their hours or work, and it treated the payments as constructive dividends to the owner. It also sustained civil fraud penalties against the owner and the company.

Can I still pay my children through my business?

Yes. Wages to family members are deductible when the work is real, the pay is reasonable for that work, and you keep records such as job descriptions, timesheets, and payroll filings. The Hee case turned on missing records, not on a rule against family employees.

What is a constructive dividend?

It is a payment a corporation makes that benefits a shareholder without being declared as a dividend. When a court finds one, the company loses the deduction and the shareholder reports the amount as income.

Why did the IRS get to go back to 2003 in this case?

Normally the IRS has three years after a return is filed to assess more tax. When a return is false or fraudulent with intent to evade tax, there is no time limit, and the court found fraud here.

Brooks Brown, EA, Tax Strategist

Brooks Brown, EA, Tax Strategist

Brooks leads Cannon & Brown Tax Advisors, a forward-thinking tax firm serving business owners in Oklahoma and beyond. He builds year-round tax strategies that help business owners keep more of what they earn and reach their goals. More about Brooks

Free Tax Analysis